capability
I can't see the ADF springing for another type of aircraft, especially if more Chinooks are purchased and the Caribous replaced with C-27's. Mind you, rumours abound regarding the type of craft being considered for the 'Bou replacement.
Suggestions I've seen touted
1) C-27 (main contender from my reading, yanks have selected it as their JCA, [some commonality with C-130?] )
2) More Chooks (a possibility I guess, given that the ADF already operate them, are supposed to be looking at buying more anyway - logistically makes some sense)
3) C-295 (long shot IMHO)
4) CV-22 ??
How many would the ADF have to acquire to get a useful capability?
The reason I ask is that if the C-27's are chosen, then there'd only be very limited funds for a CV-22 buy, and would it then be worth buying only a handful given the logistics and costs involved in supporting/crewing them?
rb
Nobody is flat spinning here, just a frank and open discussion on what we would
like to see.
I am still not sold on these Cv-22's. Have all of the bugs been ironed out? They have a bad reputation for being unreliable(unsafe?) and expensive. I would like to know the amount of maintenance hours needed per hour of flight time as opposed to the same for a chook. I think the CV-22 has about as much chance of being operated by the ADF as the RAAF has of getting CSAR choppers.

(a nice thought but outside our budget)
Extra Chinooks for Army and C-27's to replace the 'bous will be the outcome for the ADF's Tac Transport requirements, I think, but Boeing is pushing the CV-22 so anything is possible.(they must have some incriminating photo's of Nelson or something!!

)
Hooroo
Well, that is just it. The fundamental question is do you need the capability? If its no, then you buy CH-47s, If its yes, then you buy CV-22s, quite simple.
To explain: While it is particularly useful in general terms The CV-22 is in its element in high altitude environments where we (the USA) and presumably Australia will be fighting for many, many years to come.
So rather than laying down the usual mizare(?), in its proper context (what it can do and where it can go and in what environment will the ADF be fighting) , the only competive platform to the CV-22 is the CH47F.
But whereas the CH47F is slow, the CV-22 is fast.
It is actually a bit of a no brainer and aside from that, Australia doesn't need the ridiculous requirement by the USMC to restrict rotor size so that it can fit 'x' V-22s on 'y' deck. It could be optimized with the original rotors giving it better high and hot characteristics then the production version and that would really take it head and shoulders above the CH47F, because now you are toying with it being able to lift comparative combat loads.
re: the logistic question, if we are fighting a fireman response conflict as we are in Afghanistan, you need less CV-22's than you would CH47Fs to deliver the same force compnents as you can get to the battle faster. The premise of winning a fire fight in the mountains is who can bring fire power to bear faster? If you have the CV-22 that will be you, If you have the same number of CH47F's we would like to hope it would be you, but there is an element of doubt.
So getting back to logo, it would be cheaper to run less platforms then it would be to run more. Its just a case of figuring out how many platforms you need to meet operational capability that you guys are happy with. The other element is that the CV-22 gives a fire base more reach for the same number of men. Its a force multiplier over and above a chinook. Add that all up and then factor in the price tag and you come out reasonably even. Then it comes back to the original point. The question to buy is a question of desired capability.
cheers
w