Deleting a battalion from each brigade would mean the brigade would not be employable. We’re trying to find ways to make each brigade have three full manoeuvre units - going to two would be a huge step back. The US went to two manoeuvre units per brigade, and very quickly went back to three (smaller) manoeuvre units. A one battalion brigade couldn’t even meet current operational and CAPD commitments - that one battalion would become the ready battle group, and there would be nothing left to actually deploy.
If you absolutely had to reduce the size of the infantry, you’d be far better off just reducing the size of existing battalions, even if you were deleting whole rifle companies. It is relatively easy to get rifle plaroons and maybe even rifle companies out of the Reserve to backfill - you can’t get whole battalions. There is nothing compelling that sort of radical change, however.
I’d strongly argue that the manoeuvre force is about as small as you can make it. Reducing it more to fund enabling capabilities would be counter-productive, as there’s would be nothing left to enable.
I disagree.
1, 3 and 7 Bde contribute to Army's mission which is to prepare land forces to fight. Having one Bn per Bde or five per Bde does not add or take away from their ability to conduct raise-train-sustain. The reality is if we need to raise a Bde sized force to deploy we will grab units from across Army, no matter where and what they are. That includes the reset Bde if needed. So if the deployable Bde needs four manoeuvre units - then it grabs a Bn from each of the other two and adds them to its ACR and own Bn. Note that Army has already assumed there will not be a complete second rotation because of enablers and an infantry Bn is the easiest of all the units to raise quickly.
The RBG / CAPD is an interesting argument, but I think that reality has overtaken the on paper argument. By this I mean that we have already accepted Ready Bde's as having one Inf Bn - and that Bn is the RBG. Additional deployments came from outside that Bde. Plus, again, Beersheba is a RTS construct - my CAPD requirements will be met from across Army.
I don't disagree that it is easier to kill Coy and Pl than a Bn, and that it is hard to kill an Bn. But if I am faced with having to afford a whole bunch of 'stuff' that we have deemed the Army needs (IFV, CRV, tanks, rocket arty, digital radios, etc) then where am I getting the money from? The answer is to cut stuff we don't need, so what will that be? And what, of sufficient scale, can I cut to afford all of these? There are two units that, generally speaking, do not require huge amounts of training and time to stand up - a CSSB or an Inf Bn. Beersheba gives me the RTS element (meaning they don't need to be deployable, but they need to train) and I have 1 of the former and 2 of the latter. So why not cut it and role those positions and $ over?
I agree that the manoeuvre force is small, but I can still constitute a deployed Bde of 4x manoeuvre elements. So Army can still do its job. But until it gets a lot more money (unlikely), then it may have to learn to live within its means.