Smoking out some comments? Nice pun.
How can the comms comment be true?
No one who oversaw this programme could be that daft - surely?
Smoking out some comments? Nice pun.
The story is smoking out some interesting comments in the "comments" section at the bottom of the page.
old news really.
we were talking on here about 18 months ago about probs with Tigers - 18 months ago it was RAN that was jumping up and down about Tigers development and cert issues
RAAF have been unhappy for a while and the throw away line has been that Army are making up cert as they go. Some of tis might be "Service" issues. but RAN doesn't have a dog in the fight except for the fact that these things won't get off the deck of the phatships unless they comply with Navy reqs
The Navy is certainly getting ready for the Tigers.
They are practising deck handling with a full-size mockup on the dummy LHD deck on the hard-stand at Nowra.
The machine is painted grey with Navy titles... there is a shot on the adf-serials site.
The story is smoking out some interesting comments in the "comments" section at the bottom of the page.
How can the comms comment be true?
No one who oversaw this programme could be that daft - surely?
gf0012-aust said:we were talking on here about 18 months ago about probs with Tigers - 18 months ago it was RAN that was jumping up and down about Tigers development and cert issues
gf0012-aust said:RAAF have been unhappy for a while and the throw away line has been that Army are making up cert as they go. Some of tis might be "Service" issues. but RAN doesn't have a dog in the fight except for the fact that these things won't get off the deck of the phatships unless they comply with Navy reqs
Abraham Gubler said:What about the HIND? Australia does have possession of two HIND helicopters up at Tindal. They were purchased as part of the Sandline Affair but the PNG didn't want them entering the country so they have decayed away in the NT for 20 years. They still belong to Sandline after a legal dispute the PNG lost but they haven't been able to dispose of them in compliance with Australian defence export law. They tried to sell them to Nepal in '03. One imagines in a real emergency they could be used?
ADMk2 said:Never heard of such a problem with Apaches.
Sigh...
What about the HIND? Australia does have possession of two HIND helicopters up at Tindal. They were purchased as part of the Sandline Affair but the PNG didn't want them entering the country so they have decayed away in the NT for 20 years. They still belong to Sandline after a legal dispute the PNG lost but they haven't been able to dispose of them in compliance with Australian defence export law. They tried to sell them to Nepal in '03. One imagines in a real emergency they could be used?
Apaches fume. So do Super Hornet, C-17 - even Black Hawk and Kiowa. The ARH is different to the latter due to the cockpit style; but I'd rather risk an ARH than a Super Hornet or F-22. Anyhow, Apache would bring other issues to the table....
Theres also an ex-USArmy Cobra in the aviation museum in Darwin, recommision that and the B-52 and we would have some very serious close air support capability.
And IIRC, we had Cobras on order at one stage. Again, IIRC, they were cancelled by the Fraser Government.
Never head of the RAN having an issue;
ARH has steered away from the RAN after issues with FOCFT in 2010 in Sydney harbour. The focus will be back on LHDs soon (from a certification view).
Yep, like great logistical support, great interoperability and tremendous capability and a price not dissimilar to that which Eurocopter has ended up stinging us for.
But hey it can do "recon" better apparently...
Not quite; and I doubt that the price would have been what we are at now. We'd have also missed out on a fair chunk of 'stuff' that goes towards making the helicopters a capability.
The Contractor submitted a contract change proposal in September
2004 to the DMO stating that, to deliver the required services against the
15-year Through-Life-Support Contract, a significant real cost increase is
required. Defence advised the ANAO that the Department estimated that the
proposed change represented an increased cost to Defence to maintain the
ARH capability in the order of an additional 84 per cent.
We'd have also missed out on a fair chunk of 'stuff' that goes towards making the helicopters a capability.
Never head of the RAN having an issue; ARH has steered away from the RAN after issues with FOCFT in 2010 in Sydney harbour. The focus will be back on LHDs soon (from a certification view).
Not a chance. They are buggered and a government department down south has already put out the feelers to find an agency to dispose of them. Plus a Mi-24 would be behind any Western frame.
Drag them out to delamere. Easiest, cheapest option
Not a chance. They are buggered and a government department down south has already put out the feelers to find an agency to dispose of them. Plus a Mi-24 would be behind any Western frame.
Whilst I appreciate a cryptic answer as much as anyone and I know that a platform is only a part of an overall capability, I really wonder exactly what "stuff" we'd have missed if we'd chosen the short-listed AH-64D instead of the short-listed Tiger ARH for AIR-87...
I mean it's not as if we've ever heard reports of Boeing submitting a "real" through life costing 84% higher than it actually bid, unlike that which happened with Tiger, now is it?