Royal Australian Navy Discussions and Updates 2.0

Only if you stretch Hunter, I think you lose too much versatility if you give up the mission bay.

Not really an issue if you are the US Navy or PLAN, but for a fleet like the RAN where you are much more restricted on platform numbers, I think you need that versatility.

A true Type 83 like combatant taking the best bits of Type 26 and adding on top tier AAW and magazine depth as long as it was compatible with current RAN systems, sensors and weapons systems would probably be about as perfect as you could get.
So a stretched Hunter is our best option. The designs, shipyard and workers are in place. All it needs is the political will.
 
So a stretched Hunter is our best option. The designs, shipyard and workers are in place. All it needs is the political will.
I think the weight would start to be a problem if lengthened, requiring a larger propulsion plant. Making it fatter and heavier for the Hunter derivitive pushed its design to the limit.

I actually think there is every chance that big magazine destroyers could be obsolete by the time we need to replace the DDGs. Swarmed by endless enemy distributed platforms, vulnerable to tiny underwater threats.

I suspect that within 10-15 years, anything that cannot hold its own in a highly dangerous undersea environment is a dead duck as soon as it leave harbour. Ships like the HMS Daring, for instance, are going to look like the General Belgrano.

I should also note that the existing Hunters are a top end DDG in every capability except VLS capacity.
 
I mean, at least Daring has a Hull Mounted sonar, the Type 31 doesn't even get that which seems a bit insane TBH.

The only question mark for Hunter is whether they could do BMD.....
 
I think the weight would start to be a problem if lengthened, requiring a larger propulsion plant. Making it fatter and heavier for the Hunter derivitive pushed its design to the limit.

I actually think there is every chance that big magazine destroyers could be obsolete by the time we need to replace the DDGs. Swarmed by endless enemy distributed platforms, vulnerable to tiny underwater threats.

I suspect that within 10-15 years, anything that cannot hold its own in a highly dangerous undersea environment is a dead duck as soon as it leave harbour. Ships like the HMS Daring, for instance, are going to look like the General Belgrano.

I should also note that the existing Hunters are a top end DDG in every capability except VLS capacity.
So 64 VLS amidships is the way to go for a true DDG
 
I mean, at least Daring has a Hull Mounted sonar, the Type 31 doesn't even get that which seems a bit insane TBH.

The only question mark for Hunter is whether they could do BMD.....
I would have thought they have this capability in both the radar and Aegis platform and ability to launch and control SM6, just like the Hobarts.
 
So 64 VLS amidships is the way to go for a true DDG
My view is offboard storage. Keep the multi function bay for a fleet of speartooths, and travel with half a dozen small uncrewed surface vessels with 16 VLS apiece. That makes 128 VLS total. Add some more if you want additional surveillance or some extra drone/point defence capabilities.

It provides for a lot more flexibility, better redundancy and, given the cost of the current USN procurement of MUSVs, not a lot of extra cost. This type of USV might not be fully mature at the moment, but I think it will be in way less than a decade.

I would view the technology is currently good enough that if we were forced to (i.e war starts today) we could adopt it right now and live with its shortfalls for immediate capability for the Hobarts and probably the ANZACs. Hell perhaps even the Arafuras.

I just see the traditional DDG as no longer the best way to provide the capability, and it is starting to become more of a liability than a benefit. Its a big target with all the eggs in one basket.
 
My view is offboard storage. Keep the multi function bay for a fleet of speartooths, and travel with half a dozen small uncrewed surface vessels with 16 VLS apiece. That makes 128 VLS total. Add some more if you want additional surveillance or some extra drone/point defence capabilities.

It provides for a lot more flexibility, better redundancy and, given the cost of the current USN procurement of MUSVs, not a lot of extra cost. This type of USV might not be fully mature at the moment, but I think it will be in way less than a decade.

I would view the technology is currently good enough that if we were forced to (i.e war starts today) we could adopt it right now and live with its shortfalls for immediate capability for the Hobarts and probably the ANZACs. Hell perhaps even the Arafuras.

I just see the traditional DDG as no longer the best way to provide the capability, and it is starting to become more of a liability than a benefit. Its a big target with all the eggs in one basket.

Relying upon offboard VLS cells aboard unmanned platforms nearby also introduces the potential for a catastrophic single point of failure. Should something interfere, disrupt or break the link between the controlling manned platform and the unmanned platforms, then use of offboard VLS cells could stop. Similarly, should there be some sort of mechanical, electrical, or computer issue aboard unmanned platforms...

Something else to consider is how large is one actually contemplating such unmanned platforms be? For effective, bluewater ops the vessel properties of unmanned platforms are likely to be comparable to to corvette-sized manned platforms at least. Anything too much smaller will likely not be reasonably survivable in sea states potentially encountered in open ocean transits.

At some point, there is the potential for there to be no real savings or advantage with unmanned platforms due to the costs and complexity required to cover likely vignettes.
 
As I've said before, all the European designs look overloaded and top heavy. That design should be at least 20 metres longer and have double the VLS. Also , nothing is stated about power generation and directed energy weapons. Everything is crammed into it. You look at the Japanese, South Korean and Chinese designs and there's room for upgrades and additional weapons. That VLS installation reminds me of the RN mushroom farms, too much weight up top. What are they trying to emulate? A WWII IJN battleship?
AH140? The British version is almost the opposite of overloaded. What about the German F125? Definitely underloaded. And BTW, those RN mushroom farms are rather light. The cells are simple, lightweight, & small, & the missiles are light. Not a lot of weight.

The F128 is small & full, yes, but it's a quick adaptation of an existing design to get something, anything, in service ASAP because of the failure of a project to build a big, spacious ship to do the same job. It's not "all the European designs". Type 26 isn't overloaded & top heavy - except, perhaps in the RAN version. And FREMM? Look at how many VLS, & where they are.
 
Back
Top